The Butt Witch was a strange, unpredictable character. She seemed to have a deep hatred for anything childlike and innocent, and would stop at nothing to destroy it. She was also ungrateful and dismissive towards Big Deal, who tirelessly served and cared for her despite her cold attitude. Despite her mean nature, there were moments where her vulnerability shone through. When Big Deal began to spend time with the island inhabitants in disguise as Reggie, her reaction was one of sadness and envy, hinting at a deeper insecurity within her.